The auth issue of the sell orders posed by Upstox and Zerodha led the Indian financial markets on a whole new tangent which was unthought of. The root cause of this however has been linked to the disruption of the Central Depository Services Limited system which is core to the working of the market. This disruption has now created problems to a number of brokers and as such has created a great deal of turmoil for traders and investors.
Understanding the CDSL Issue
In India, there are two depositories: CDSL and NSDL (National Securities Depository Limited). It is important in the stock market as it holds and trades securities in dematerialized form. For a sell order to be processed, CDSL has to endorse the securities placed for sale with the demat account of the investor with the CDSL system. This process ensures that only authentic and legal securities that belong to the seller are allowed to be placed in trade.
The problem highlighted grabbed only one eye of CDSL that led to brokers being unable to accept or enter any sell side quota which a client wishes to set up. Trying to patrol the clouds of soaring prices, individual investors flooded in the market with share selling orders and in turn faced failures as well. Thus expectations of them were crushed and they were left unsatisfied especially as they wanted to take advantage of volatile market conditions.
Effects on Traders and Brokers
There was CDSL flaws which were not self contained and thus affected the entire bandwagon of stock brokers including Zerodha and Upstox.
Both platforms acknowledged the problem arising from social media, making certain to keep all of its users up to speed. For instance, Zerodha said, “Due to a technical malfunction at CDSL, authorizations for sell orders are failing.” This problem is affecting all the brokers. We are in touch with CDSL to hasten the recovery. Upsostok expressed the same comment in similar terms.
This problem affects many traders in times when the ordinary trend has many position shifts or if they want to get out of the mesh. In particular only intraday traders suffered losses because they were not able to sell out their holdings. Many took to social media to air their grievances and dissatisfaction over the lack of adequate preparedness and response by the brokers as well as CDSL to the outcries and complaints.
Comments and Actions from Brokers
In an effort to ease the discomfort that users felt the brokers had to implement some measures as provisional ones. Zerodha, on the other hand, allowed its clients to authorise shares using the eDIS T-PIN method CDSL’s fallback procedure. Upstox did the same and gave instructions to customers on how to place sell orders utilizing different options. All the same, these methods were not very helpful as they took more steps and longer time to conclude trades.
Some brokers urged their clients not to touch anything until the situation was under control, but these es came with clear warnings. This tactic, while default given in this sort of situation, was lambasted by those clients who expected all such cases to be fixed quickly as possible.
Market Ramifications
The CDSL incident occurred when the stock market was up and active, thereby increasing its impact strength into the markets.
The centralization of a number of sell orders in the system led to liquidity issues which in turn led to some equities experiencing extreme price volatility caused by excess buying or selling. This revolved about focusing on the amount of selling and purchasing owing to the dependence the financial system had on other institutions and its trailing consequences caused due to technical issues.
Another issue that the incident raised was the adequacy of the technological structure that meets the requirements of the dynamic member base in the Indian market. Over the last few years, the balance of power has shifted towards retail investors in large numbers and hence the resiliency of important components has become the order of day.
Regulatory and Technological Barriers
This episode is expected to put CDSL and the brokers in question through a thorough scrutiny. The independent residents and regulators authorities like SEBI (Securities and Exchange Board of India) may give explanations and offer the securities to prevent the recurrences of such cases in the future. The investment resources have to be fortified with more adequate computer resources together with optimal routing strategies.
The breakdown accentuates the need for demat and their members’ brokers to build more robust and scalable systems. Bring more orders- and most importantly infrastructure- to enable quick and firm order targets and have a strong target even under great technical pressure.
Final Thoughts
The indurative reason on why this has happened on a CDSL level, eventually will serve to force order out of chaos over what barriers the cause of the selling volume rate was central to several brokers.
The issue highlighted how some areas need strengthening. All this has left investors with a day of anger and missed opportunities as brokers like Zerodha and Upstox kept talking to their clients and suggested stopgap measures.
More importantly, going ahead, joint strategies of depositories, brokers, and regulators will be necessary to ensure such interruptions are minimized. Not only will these help restore confidence, but it will also improve the overall trading climate in the country as well.
If you are interested for more: The problem with CDSL affecting multiple brokers Remarkable catch by Smith dismisses Rahul as India concludes lunch at 167-6.